rating: 3 of 5 stars
I guess this would be more of a 3.5. (Hey GoodReads, why can’t I give half stars?!)
Basically, my problem with this book all stems from the fact that I don’t believe the underlying premise that there can be HEA with three men and one woman. I’m sure it’s me, but I don’t think I’d like to share. I have a problem suspending my disbelief long enough to think that the three guys would all be happy sharing one lady they all loved.
So, if you don’t buy in to the book on the most fundamental level, how can it get three stars? Well, because I loved all the characters. Towards the middle, Reggie started to get on my nerves, but I have a notorious problem with heroine(s). I either love them or hate them. Overall, she was a win for me. I liked her attitude and her determination. I like how she had to give in and became part of a group instead of just an individual. I loved how she stood up to her parents. I liked her relationship with her partner and her boss. She was great. The boys were equally fantastic. I thought Banks did a really good job giving each one their own space for development. And that is partly why the rest of the book didn’t work for me. It felt like they were all cheated out of the HEA that each deserved. I preferred her with Hutch, and I thought Cam and Sawyer (God, I loved Sawyer) deserved their own books. Even though they were all three dimensionally developed, I wanted to know MORE about them. I don’t know, I just didn’t feel like they were done. Did I mention how much I loved Sawyer?
The creepy stalker plot was enough to move the story along, but I could have used more there as well. I never really felt like it was an imminent threat. It was, of course, but I was too busy trying to figure out how the relationships were going to work to care about anything else. I think if it would have been just a story about her and Hutch, then it would have fallen into place easier for me. I did like the revelation of the stalker, and I wanted to feel badly for that person (and I think I was supposed to) but by that time, I didn’t care about any of that anymore. I was invested somewhere else, and just wanted it to be over so we could get back home to see THAT resolution.
So, I liked the book. I did. I’m looking forward to reading more books by Maya Banks, but I wish two of the guys would have gotten more love.